Bobby Bare Jr. was five when his father placed him beside a studio microphone and let him ask a string of impossible childhood questions. Shel Silverstein had written “Daddy What If” as a conversation between a boy and his father. Bare did not polish the child out of the recording. His son’s small voice, uncertain timing and complete trust were the reason the song worked. Released on Lullabys, Legends and Lies, it reached No. 2 on the country chart in 1973. Television producers noticed. The Bare family followed with Singin’ in the Kitchen, an informal album featuring Bobby’s wife, Jeannie, and their children Cari, Shannon and Bobby Jr. For one summer, the family traveled and performed together. There was an obvious commercial future available. Bare ended it. When Hee Haw wanted to hire Bobby Jr. after the children appeared on the show, his father said no. He had enjoyed making the records with them, but he did not want his son living inside the attention given to a successful child performer. Bobby Jr. later remembered that his parents removed the children from entertainment because they did not want them becoming washed-up performers before reaching their teens. The decision carries additional weight beside Bare’s own childhood. His mother died when he was five—the same age his son was when they recorded “Daddy What If.” His father could not support three children alone, and the family was divided among relatives and neighbors. By fifteen, Bobby was working on farms and in factories. Fame had finally given him the money to keep a family together. He would not allow fame to reorganize that family around itself. Bobby Jr. eventually became a musician, but he returned as an adult and chose a harder, noisier path far outside his father’s shadow. In 2005, he produced The Moon Was Blue for the elder Bare. By then, the little boy had acquired his own voice. His father had helped preserve the years in which he was allowed to find it.

“Scroll down to the end of the article to listen to music.”

BOBBY BARE GAVE HIS CHILDREN ONE SUMMER IN SHOW BUSINESS

The microphone was low enough for a five-year-old.

Bobby Bare stood nearby while his son worked through “Daddy What If,” Shel Silverstein’s chain of questions about a world in which familiar things suddenly stopped behaving as they should. Bobby Jr. did not sing like a trained child entertainer. He sounded like a boy talking to his father.

That was the record’s center. The famous voice supplied reassurance; the smaller voice made reassurance necessary.

When the song became a hit, Nashville saw a new act it could sell. Bare saw something with a shorter life.

The Age of Five

Bobby Bare understood five-year-old uncertainty from the other side.

His mother died in 1941, when he was five. His father, unable to care for all three children, separated the household. Bobby’s younger sister was adopted by a family down the road. His older sister moved among grandparents and relatives. Bobby himself was passed between homes.

The disruption did not provide a tidy origin story. It established that family arrangements could change without asking a child whether he was ready.

Bare later worked on a farm and in factories. He built a crude guitar from a coffee can, a stick and strands of screen wire, then imagined a different life long before he possessed an instrument capable of producing it.

By the time his own children arrived, he had crossed nearly every distance country music could offer: factory work to radio, unsuccessful records to “Detroit City,” rented rooms to a stable Nashville household.

The son beside him at the microphone had not been required to make that journey.

A Song Built Like a Conversation

Bare had become one of Nashville’s most alert song finders. He recognized material from writers who did not fit neatly into the industry and gave their work room to retain its strangeness.

Shel Silverstein fit naturally into that world. His songs could move from tenderness to mischief without warning, and Bare resisted the urge to make them respectable.

Their 1973 double album, Lullabys, Legends and Lies, gathered ghost stories, tall tales, children’s questions and adult trouble. Bare produced the project himself at a time when Nashville singers were rarely given that authority.

“Daddy What If” needed neither an orchestra nor a theatrical child vocalist. Bobby Jr.’s presence turned it from a clever composition into a family exchange accidentally captured on tape.

The single climbed to No. 2. Bare’s only chart-topping country record, “Marie Laveau,” came from the same Silverstein collection. His creative freedom and family life had entered the same successful album.

Everybody in the Kitchen

The next project widened the doorway.

Singin’ in the Kitchen brought Jeannie Bare and the children—Cari, Shannon and Bobby Jr.—into an album made largely from Silverstein material. The arrangements preserved conversation, jokes and the loose timing of people who knew one another better than they knew the studio.

Jeannie was not merely a star’s wife coaxed toward a microphone. She had sung professionally and possessed a strong country voice of her own. The album gave her several featured moments while allowing the children to remain children rather than miniature adult performers.

Its informality was carefully protected. Interviews and bits of family talk appeared between songs. The cover placed the Bares around a kitchen table, locating the project in the room where most families already made noise together.

They took the record on the road for a summer. Bobby Jr. remembered wanting to be onstage because that was where his father stood. For a child, imitation could look exactly like vocation.

Bare did not assume they were the same thing.

The Offer From Hee Haw

The children appeared on Hee Haw, contributing the witch’s scream used in “Marie Laveau.” The program wanted to hire Bobby Jr.

Bare declined.

A continuing television job could have made his son independently famous. It might also have changed the structure of the household: schedules, rehearsals, adult praise, ratings and income would begin gathering around a seven-year-old.

Bare later explained that he wanted the children to remain children. Bobby Jr. recalled his parents’ concern that early entertainment success could leave a person receiving unnatural attention and feeling finished before adolescence was over.

After the family tour, the act stopped. There was no long campaign to produce another hit duet, no sequence of matching outfits and no attempt to turn the Bare surname into a permanent television property.

The hit remained available. The child did not.

A House Full of Songwriters

Keeping Bobby Jr. out of professional child stardom did not mean keeping him away from music.

The Bare household attracted writers. Silverstein became close enough to function as an unruly extended-family member. Other songwriters passed through as friends, collaborators and guests. Later, when Bare hosted Bobby Bare and Friends, the conversations revolved around the person who had made the song as much as the performer who could sell it.

Bobby Jr. absorbed that hierarchy. He later said that in his family there was no occupation held higher than songwriting.

What his parents withheld was not music but the machinery that could make a child confuse applause with identity. He heard songs argued over, rewritten and passed from hand to hand. He also went back to school when the family’s brief touring experiment ended.

As an adult, he chose rock clubs, loud guitars and original material that did not resemble a careful continuation of his father’s career. The distance confirmed that the choice belonged to him.

The Record Made in Return

In 2005, the direction of work reversed.

Bobby Bare had been largely absent from recording for years when his son produced The Moon Was Blue. The younger Bare did not try to manufacture an updated version of “Detroit City.” He placed his father inside a spacious, late-night collection of songs suited to an older voice.

The child once guided through a duet was now listening from the control room, making decisions about arrangements, performances and what should be left untouched.

Their relationship had survived the dangerous usefulness of “Daddy What If.” The early hit had not consumed the son’s childhood or obliged him to reenact it in middle age.

They could work together because they had also been allowed to live separately.

What Bobby Bare’s Family Record Really Leaves Behind

Singin’ in the Kitchen never became the foundation of a dynasty act. Its value lies partly in that refusal.

It preserved Jeannie’s voice, the children at particular ages and a household relaxed enough to sound untidy. Then Bobby Bare closed the professional door before the record business could decide that the children owed it a sequel.

Bobby Jr. still became a musician. His father did not prevent the choice; he postponed the industry’s power to make it for him.

Years later, father and son could meet in a studio without recreating the small boy and protective father from 1973. One sat behind the microphone. The other listened from the control room.

This time, nobody needed to lower the microphone.

Video

Related Post

A Doctor Told Roy Rogers and Dale Evans to Put Their Baby Away. They Took Her Home. After Robin Elizabeth Rogers was born in August 1950, a doctor advised Roy Rogers and Dale Evans to place their daughter in an institution. Robin had Down syndrome and a serious heart defect. The doctor warned that she might not live long and that caring for her would take attention away from the other children in the Rogers household. In mid-century America, when children with intellectual disabilities were frequently hidden from public life, the recommendation was not unusual. Roy answered that they would take Robin home. At the time, he and Dale were among the most recognizable entertainers in America. Roy had announced Robin’s birth to a rodeo crowd of roughly 90,000 people. Their films, radio appearances and merchandise presented a bright Western world where good people always found their way safely home. The private reality awaiting them was more fragile: medical appointments, constant vigilance and a child vulnerable to illnesses her body had little strength to resist. Robin lived within the family rather than apart from it. Dale later said that those two years changed the household’s understanding of patience, faith and responsibility. Then mumps passed through the family. Robin developed encephalitis and died on August 24, 1952, two days before her second birthday. Dale responded by writing a small book. Published in 1953, Angel Unaware was only sixty-three pages long and told Robin’s story as though the child were speaking to God after returning to heaven. It was openly religious and deeply personal, but its public consequence reached beyond the Rogers family. Dale had written plainly about raising and loving a child whom many parents of that era would have been urged to conceal. The book became one of the year’s bestsellers. At appearances, parents began bringing children with Down syndrome out to meet Dale—children who had seldom been taken into stores, theaters or large public gatherings because their families expected rejection. That same year, a group of Oklahoma parents established a school for children with developmental disabilities. After reading Angel Unaware, they named it for Dale. The organization eventually became the Dale Rogers Training Center, providing employment and support services far beyond its original classroom. Roy Rogers spent his career playing a cowboy who brought people safely home. With Robin, he did something quieter. He refused to send his own child away.

For nearly two years, Wanda Jackson and Wendell Goodman stopped traveling and tried to become full-time parents. It should have corrected an old imbalance. Their daughter Gina and son Greg had grown up with nannies, weekends at their grandparents’ house and parents whose work was measured in hotel rooms and distant stages. Wanda later admitted that she carried guilt about the childhood they had been given. Yet when the suitcases stayed unpacked, the household did not settle into the life she imagined. Wanda was unhappy. Wendell was unhappy. Most unexpectedly, the children were not accustomed to having both parents home all the time. The family had spent years learning how to remain connected through departures; constant togetherness required another set of habits entirely. Their unusual arrangement had begun shortly after Wanda and Wendell married in 1961. He left a promising career in computers to travel with her, eventually becoming her booking agent and manager. Gina was born in 1962 and Greg in 1964. Wanda worked while her parents and trusted caregivers supplied the daily continuity that touring could not. In 1971, Wanda and Wendell converted to Christianity and began reconsidering the order of their lives. She left the nightclub circuit and concentrated on gospel music. Wendell became part of the programs as a speaker. Even this attempt to place faith and family ahead of career did not remove the road; it simply changed where the family’s income came from and what happened after the curtain opened. When their experiment with staying home failed, Wanda and Wendell resumed traveling with the support of the people who had always helped care for the children. She did not claim that the decision erased her guilt. She only acknowledged that singing was the work through which she knew how to live. Years later, Gina and Greg were grown, gospel bookings had diminished, and European audiences began calling Wanda back to the rockabilly songs America had largely forgotten. Wendell reorganized the calendar once more. The Jackson children had not been raised inside an ordinary home. They had been raised inside an arrangement—grandparents, caregivers, telephone calls, returns and departures—held together imperfectly by more hands than the audience ever saw.

Donna Reed Was Never Only the Woman Hollywood Asked Her to Play At seventeen, Donnabelle Mullenger left an Iowa farm for Los Angeles because her family could not afford the college education she wanted. She stayed with an aunt, enrolled at Los Angeles City College and supported herself by washing dishes and performing clerical work. A campus beauty contest led to a screen test. MGM signed her, changed her name to Donna Reed and placed her in a succession of wholesome supporting roles. During World War II, servicemen wrote to her from barracks, tunnels and battlefields; she personally answered many and kept 341 of their letters. In 1946, Reed played Mary Bailey in It’s a Wonderful Life. The film was not immediately the American institution it later became, but Mary’s steadiness fixed Reed inside the public imagination as the woman who could hold a home together. Reed spent years trying to move beyond that image. In From Here to Eternity, she played Lorene, a nightclub hostess living far from Bedford Falls. The performance earned her the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress. Her greatest popular success came through television. The Donna Reed Show ran from 1958 through 1966, placing a mother rather than a father at the center of a family sitcom. Behind the camera, Reed exercised substantial creative control, studying lighting and cinematography while working as an uncredited producer. When the series ended, she stepped back from regular acting, raised her children and became active against the Vietnam War. She served as a leading figure in Another Mother for Peace, opposed nuclear power and campaigned for Eugene McCarthy in 1968. Her final major role came in 1984 when she replaced Barbara Bel Geddes as Miss Ellie on Dallas. When the producers brought Bel Geddes back and removed Reed, she sued, arguing that she had been hired as the character—not as a temporary stand-in. The case was settled in 1985. Reed received her contracted salary and the freedom to work elsewhere. That December, doctors discovered pancreatic cancer. She died at home on January 14, 1986, thirteen days before her sixty-fifth birthday. Her final professional dispute had not concerned applause or nostalgia. It concerned whether a woman with four decades of work could still insist that her name on a contract meant exactly what it said.

You Missed

A Doctor Told Roy Rogers and Dale Evans to Put Their Baby Away. They Took Her Home. After Robin Elizabeth Rogers was born in August 1950, a doctor advised Roy Rogers and Dale Evans to place their daughter in an institution. Robin had Down syndrome and a serious heart defect. The doctor warned that she might not live long and that caring for her would take attention away from the other children in the Rogers household. In mid-century America, when children with intellectual disabilities were frequently hidden from public life, the recommendation was not unusual. Roy answered that they would take Robin home. At the time, he and Dale were among the most recognizable entertainers in America. Roy had announced Robin’s birth to a rodeo crowd of roughly 90,000 people. Their films, radio appearances and merchandise presented a bright Western world where good people always found their way safely home. The private reality awaiting them was more fragile: medical appointments, constant vigilance and a child vulnerable to illnesses her body had little strength to resist. Robin lived within the family rather than apart from it. Dale later said that those two years changed the household’s understanding of patience, faith and responsibility. Then mumps passed through the family. Robin developed encephalitis and died on August 24, 1952, two days before her second birthday. Dale responded by writing a small book. Published in 1953, Angel Unaware was only sixty-three pages long and told Robin’s story as though the child were speaking to God after returning to heaven. It was openly religious and deeply personal, but its public consequence reached beyond the Rogers family. Dale had written plainly about raising and loving a child whom many parents of that era would have been urged to conceal. The book became one of the year’s bestsellers. At appearances, parents began bringing children with Down syndrome out to meet Dale—children who had seldom been taken into stores, theaters or large public gatherings because their families expected rejection. That same year, a group of Oklahoma parents established a school for children with developmental disabilities. After reading Angel Unaware, they named it for Dale. The organization eventually became the Dale Rogers Training Center, providing employment and support services far beyond its original classroom. Roy Rogers spent his career playing a cowboy who brought people safely home. With Robin, he did something quieter. He refused to send his own child away.

Bobby Bare Jr. was five when his father placed him beside a studio microphone and let him ask a string of impossible childhood questions. Shel Silverstein had written “Daddy What If” as a conversation between a boy and his father. Bare did not polish the child out of the recording. His son’s small voice, uncertain timing and complete trust were the reason the song worked. Released on Lullabys, Legends and Lies, it reached No. 2 on the country chart in 1973. Television producers noticed. The Bare family followed with Singin’ in the Kitchen, an informal album featuring Bobby’s wife, Jeannie, and their children Cari, Shannon and Bobby Jr. For one summer, the family traveled and performed together. There was an obvious commercial future available. Bare ended it. When Hee Haw wanted to hire Bobby Jr. after the children appeared on the show, his father said no. He had enjoyed making the records with them, but he did not want his son living inside the attention given to a successful child performer. Bobby Jr. later remembered that his parents removed the children from entertainment because they did not want them becoming washed-up performers before reaching their teens. The decision carries additional weight beside Bare’s own childhood. His mother died when he was five—the same age his son was when they recorded “Daddy What If.” His father could not support three children alone, and the family was divided among relatives and neighbors. By fifteen, Bobby was working on farms and in factories. Fame had finally given him the money to keep a family together. He would not allow fame to reorganize that family around itself. Bobby Jr. eventually became a musician, but he returned as an adult and chose a harder, noisier path far outside his father’s shadow. In 2005, he produced The Moon Was Blue for the elder Bare. By then, the little boy had acquired his own voice. His father had helped preserve the years in which he was allowed to find it.

For nearly two years, Wanda Jackson and Wendell Goodman stopped traveling and tried to become full-time parents. It should have corrected an old imbalance. Their daughter Gina and son Greg had grown up with nannies, weekends at their grandparents’ house and parents whose work was measured in hotel rooms and distant stages. Wanda later admitted that she carried guilt about the childhood they had been given. Yet when the suitcases stayed unpacked, the household did not settle into the life she imagined. Wanda was unhappy. Wendell was unhappy. Most unexpectedly, the children were not accustomed to having both parents home all the time. The family had spent years learning how to remain connected through departures; constant togetherness required another set of habits entirely. Their unusual arrangement had begun shortly after Wanda and Wendell married in 1961. He left a promising career in computers to travel with her, eventually becoming her booking agent and manager. Gina was born in 1962 and Greg in 1964. Wanda worked while her parents and trusted caregivers supplied the daily continuity that touring could not. In 1971, Wanda and Wendell converted to Christianity and began reconsidering the order of their lives. She left the nightclub circuit and concentrated on gospel music. Wendell became part of the programs as a speaker. Even this attempt to place faith and family ahead of career did not remove the road; it simply changed where the family’s income came from and what happened after the curtain opened. When their experiment with staying home failed, Wanda and Wendell resumed traveling with the support of the people who had always helped care for the children. She did not claim that the decision erased her guilt. She only acknowledged that singing was the work through which she knew how to live. Years later, Gina and Greg were grown, gospel bookings had diminished, and European audiences began calling Wanda back to the rockabilly songs America had largely forgotten. Wendell reorganized the calendar once more. The Jackson children had not been raised inside an ordinary home. They had been raised inside an arrangement—grandparents, caregivers, telephone calls, returns and departures—held together imperfectly by more hands than the audience ever saw.

Donna Reed Was Never Only the Woman Hollywood Asked Her to Play At seventeen, Donnabelle Mullenger left an Iowa farm for Los Angeles because her family could not afford the college education she wanted. She stayed with an aunt, enrolled at Los Angeles City College and supported herself by washing dishes and performing clerical work. A campus beauty contest led to a screen test. MGM signed her, changed her name to Donna Reed and placed her in a succession of wholesome supporting roles. During World War II, servicemen wrote to her from barracks, tunnels and battlefields; she personally answered many and kept 341 of their letters. In 1946, Reed played Mary Bailey in It’s a Wonderful Life. The film was not immediately the American institution it later became, but Mary’s steadiness fixed Reed inside the public imagination as the woman who could hold a home together. Reed spent years trying to move beyond that image. In From Here to Eternity, she played Lorene, a nightclub hostess living far from Bedford Falls. The performance earned her the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress. Her greatest popular success came through television. The Donna Reed Show ran from 1958 through 1966, placing a mother rather than a father at the center of a family sitcom. Behind the camera, Reed exercised substantial creative control, studying lighting and cinematography while working as an uncredited producer. When the series ended, she stepped back from regular acting, raised her children and became active against the Vietnam War. She served as a leading figure in Another Mother for Peace, opposed nuclear power and campaigned for Eugene McCarthy in 1968. Her final major role came in 1984 when she replaced Barbara Bel Geddes as Miss Ellie on Dallas. When the producers brought Bel Geddes back and removed Reed, she sued, arguing that she had been hired as the character—not as a temporary stand-in. The case was settled in 1985. Reed received her contracted salary and the freedom to work elsewhere. That December, doctors discovered pancreatic cancer. She died at home on January 14, 1986, thirteen days before her sixty-fifth birthday. Her final professional dispute had not concerned applause or nostalgia. It concerned whether a woman with four decades of work could still insist that her name on a contract meant exactly what it said.